The ICA’s Creative Advisory Committee, chaired by Brent Choi, decided on a methodology that will be used to create the 2027 Creative Power List based on performance in 2026. Supported by leading audit, tax, and consulting firm, Doane Grant Thornton LLP, the ICA will publish the 2027 rankings in Q1 2027.
Tier 1 shows:
- Cannes Lions
- D&AD Awards
- The One Show
Tier 2 shows:
- ADCC Awards
- Clio Awards
- Effie Awards Canada
- London International Awards
Tier 3 shows:
- ADC Awards
- Applied Arts Awards
- Marketing Awards
Building a tiered weighting:
The aim of the revised methodology is to allow each tier to contribute an approximate percentage towards the overall of the scoring: Tier 1, 50%, Tier 2, 30% and Tier 3, 20%. The contribution distribution considered the number of awards delivered by each program. As an example:
Example - Tier 2
| ADCC | Clio | Effie Canada |
|---|
| Grand/Best in Show | n/a | 2 | 1 |
| Gold | 52 | 11 | 3 |
| Silver | 121 | 28 | 15 |
| Bronze | 186 | 37 | 22 |
| Shortlist/Finalist | 131 | 48 | 23 |
| Total | 490 | 126 | 64 |
This approach delivered a scoring mechanic as follows:
Tier 1
| Cannes |
|
|---|
| Creative Effectiveness Grand Prix | 2194 |
| Grand Prix | 1536 |
| Titanium Lion | 1317 |
| Gold Lion | 1097 |
| Silver Lion | 658 |
| Bronze Lion | 439 |
| Shortlist | 44 |
| D&AD |
|
|---|
| Black Pencil | 2132 |
| Yellow or White Pencil | 1066 |
| Graphite Pencil | 640 |
| Wood Pencil | 426 |
| Shortlist | 43 |
| The One Show |
|
|---|
| Best of Show | 1040 |
| Best of Discipline Pencil | 831 |
| Gold Pencil | 520 |
| Silver Pencil | 312 |
| Bronze Pencil | 208 |
| Merit | 21 |
Tier 2
| Clios |
|
|---|
| Grand | 222 |
| Gold | 159 |
| Silver | 95 |
| Bronze | 63 |
| Shortlist | 6 |
| Effie Awards |
|
|---|
| Grand | 454 |
| Gold | 324 |
| Silver | 195 |
| Bronze | 130 |
| Finalist | 13 |
| ADCC |
|
|---|
| Best | 66 |
| Gold | 48 |
| Silver | 29 |
| Bronze | 20 |
| Shortlist | 1 |
| LIA |
|
|---|
| Grand Prix | 222 |
| Gold | 159 |
| Silver | 95 |
| Bronze | 63 |
| Finalist | 6 |
Tier 3
| Marketing |
|
|---|
| Best of Show or M for Impact | 149 |
| Gold | 107 |
| Silver | 64 |
| Bronze | 42 |
| Shortlist | 4 |
| ADC |
|
|---|
| Best Cube | 149 |
| Designism or Fusion Cube | 149 |
| Gold Cube | 107 |
| Silver Cube | 64 |
| Bronze Cube | 42 |
| Merit | 4 |
This scoring mechanism will apply in 2026, giving the industry clear visibility into how each award show contributes to overall rankings. The Creative Advisory Committee will review industry feedback at the end of 2026 and confirm the scoring framework for the 2028 Creative Power List.
Co / Joint Entries
Sometimes entries to award shows are made as co / joint-submissions either by multiple agencies or by the same agency but multiple offices. The points allocated will be divided equally between each entrant in the creation of the Creative Power List.
Canadian Creative Power
The Creative Advisory Committee welcomes feedback on this initiative and its methodology. It is created by the industry for the industry. Please email any feedback to scott@theica.ca.
To learn more about the Creative Power List and view previous years, click here.